MARKET INDEX
KOSPI5,100.50▼ 3.59%
KOSDAQ665.65▼ 4.86%
S&P 5007,416.59▼ 1.92%
NASDAQ24,509.76▼ 2.49%
USD/KRW1,335.48▲ 0.37 (+0.03%)
WTI Crude$85.28▼ 0.51%
BTC/USD$64,770▼ 0.83%
KOSPI5,100.50▼ 3.59%
KOSDAQ665.65▼ 4.86%
S&P 5007,416.59▼ 1.92%
NASDAQ24,509.76▼ 2.49%
USD/KRW1,335.48▲ 0.37 (+0.03%)
WTI Crude$85.28▼ 0.51%
BTC/USD$64,770▼ 0.83%
헤더 좌
헤더 우
BREAKING
MARKET Times 공식 배너

Samsung and SK Hynix Face Antitrust Scrutiny in U.S. Over DRAM Supply Strategies

A U.S. court has denied a motion to dismiss a class-action lawsuit alleging that Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron colluded to restrict DRAM supply.

Samsung and SK Hynix Face Antitrust Scrutiny in U.S. Over DRAM Supply Strategies
MTIMES Archive / Photo

U.S. Court Denies Motion to Dismiss DRAM Antitrust Lawsuit Against Three Memory Giants; Focus Shifts to Production Cuts and DDR4 Supply Constraints

Companies Face Scrutiny Over Passive Capacity Expansion Despite Surging DRAM Prices; Legal Battle Intensifies Over Production Capabilities and Contract Terms

A U.S. federal court has denied a motion by Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron to dismiss a class-action lawsuit alleging price-fixing in the DRAM market. The legal battle centers on whether the companies' strategic shift toward High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) and concurrent production cuts for general-purpose DRAM constitute evidence of anti-competitive supply restrictions.

On the 16th, South Korean markets saw Samsung Electronics and SK hynix shares tumble by over 4% and 7%, respectively, dragging the KOSPI index down. The semiconductor sector is already grappling with uncertainties regarding U.S. interest rates and AI investment, and the DRAM antitrust litigation has further intensified pressure on the domestic memory industry.

HBM Long-term Contracts and DDR4 Cuts: The Court's Focus on Supply Strategy

The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California ruled on the 14th that the plaintiffs' allegations regarding production cuts and supply restrictions were sufficiently specific to warrant a trial on potential collusion.

Seventeen plaintiffs, including U.S. consumers and small businesses, argue that the three memory manufacturers began reducing production in late 2022 and artificially constrained the supply of general-purpose DRAM by shifting capacity toward HBM.

The plaintiffs also pointed to the companies' simultaneous announcements regarding DDR4 production cuts for the second quarter of 2025 and the adoption of similar customer order review procedures earlier this year as evidence of potential coordination.

In their joint motion to dismiss, Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron argued that each company made independent production and investment decisions based on market conditions and profitability. They maintained that the reduction in DDR4 production was a standard business decision reflecting the market's transition toward DDR5.

While the court acknowledged that expanding HBM production could be a rational business choice, it noted that the simultaneous implementation of difficult-to-reverse decisions—such as allocating capacity to long-term contracts and reducing supply of legacy products—merits further investigation.

Judge Noel Wise remarked in the ruling that the plaintiffs' evidence suggests the competitors were acting less like independent entities and more like "hawks flying in formation." The court also noted the industry's history of price-fixing between 1998 and 2002 as relevant context.

Supply Constraints Amid Price Surges: Assessing Actual Production Capacity

A key issue in the upcoming proceedings will be the maintenance of production cuts even after DRAM prices began to rise. The plaintiffs allege that despite improved profitability in general-purpose DRAM, the three companies failed to expand supply.

According to the court filing, plaintiffs claim that contract prices for general-purpose DRAM rose by approximately 697% over an 18-month period ending in the first quarter of 2026—a figure provided by the plaintiffs rather than verified market statistics.

However, industry experts note that price increases do not automatically translate to immediate production expansion. Semiconductor production lines are highly specialized, and HBM production schedules are dictated by customer certifications and long-term supply agreements. Converting capacity already committed to HBM back to general-purpose DRAM would require significant adjustments to existing contracts and investment plans.

The court acknowledged that determining which product was more profitable is difficult at this stage, as both sides have presented conflicting data. The central question remains whether the companies were unable to increase production or if they intentionally restricted supply in coordination with competitors.

The court's decision merely allows the case to proceed to discovery and trial; it does not confirm collusion. The three memory companies are required to submit their responses by December 7, with the first case management conference scheduled for January 12 of next year.

MARKET Times

MTIMES Global Editorial Statement

This analysis is provided for international business intelligence and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell securities. For inquiries regarding licensing or syndication, please contact [email protected].

← More in CorporateBack to Top ↑

Related Market & Corporate Intelligence

Global Oil Market Divergence: Crude Surplus Meets Persistent Diesel TightnessGlobal Oil Market Divergence: Crude Surplus Meets Persistent Diesel TightnessFed Warns of Hidden Risks in Big Tech AI Investment SurgeFed Warns of Hidden Risks in Big Tech AI Investment SurgeEuropean Equities See Largest Inflow in Five Years as Investor Focus Shifts from US TechEuropean Equities See Largest Inflow in Five Years as Investor Focus Shifts from US TechCan KOSDAQ Revitalization Succeed? Focus Shifts to Delisting Insolvent FirmsCan KOSDAQ Revitalization Succeed? Focus Shifts to Delisting Insolvent Firms
HomeTOP10AlmatenPicksCorpAlgiten